Text of Barack Obama’s constituent Email response letter for FISA HR 6304

That was quick. Just yesterday I was bemoaning the busy signals emanating from the telephone lines of my U.S. senators, and decided to write some emails while I was waiting to get through to ask them to support the Dodd/Feingold filibuster against FISA HR 6304. Now today already I have a response from one of them–Sen. Barack Obama.

Any diehard groupthink Obama koolaid drinkers should be sitting down before they attempt to read this.

Dear Nijma: (no, he didn’t really say “Nijma” but he did use my first name)

Thank you for contacting me concerning the President’s domestic surveillance program. I appreciate hearing from you.

Providing any President with the flexibility necessary to fight terrorism without compromising our constitutional rights can be a delicate balance. I agree that technological advances and changes in the nature of the threat our nation faces may require that the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), enacted in 1978, be updated to reflect the reality of the post 9/11 world. But that does not absolve the President of the responsibility to fully brief Congress on the new security challenge and to work cooperatively with Congress to address it.

As you know, Congress has been considering the issue of domestic surveillance since last year. Just before the August recess in 2007, Congress passed hastily crafted legislation to expand the authority of the Attorney General and the Director of National Intelligence to conduct surveillance of suspected foreign terrorists without a warrant or real oversight, even if the targets are communicating with someone in the United States. This legislation was signed into law by the President on August 5, 2007.

As you are aware, Congress has been working on reforms to FISA. On November 15, 2007, the House of Representatives passed H.R. 3773, the “Responsible Electronic Surveillance That is Overseen, Reviewed, and Effective Act of 2007” (RESTORE Act) by a vote of 227-189. The House bill did not provide retroactive immunity for private companies that may have participated in the illegal collection of personal information, nor does it provide immunity for Administration officials who may have acted illegally.

On February 12, 2008, the Senate passed S. 2248, making its own reforms to FISA. During consideration of this bill, I was proud to cosponsor several amendments, including the Dodd-Feingold amendment to strike the immunity provision, which would have enhanced privacy protections while maintaining the tools to fight terrorism. However, with the defeat of this amendment, the bill did not provide for a mechanism that would allow the American people to learn exactly what the Bush Administration did with its warrantless wiretapping program and provided for no accountability.

The House and Senate worked out a compromise, reconciling differences between the two versions of the bill before it can be signed into law. While I recognize that this compromise is imperfect, I will support this legislation, which provides an important tool to fight the war on terrorism and provides for an Inspectors General report so that we can finally get to the bottom of the warrantless wiretapping program and how it undermined our civil liberties. However, I am disappointed that this bill, if signed into law, will grant an unprecedented level of immunity for telecommunications companies that cooperated with the President’s warrantless wiretapping program, and I will work with my colleagues to remove this provision.

The American people understand that new threats require flexible responses to keep them safe, and that our intelligence gathering capability needs to be improved. What they do not want is for the President or the Congress to use these imperatives as a pretext for promoting policies that not only go further than necessary to meet a real threat, but also violate some of the most basic tenets of our democracy. Like most members of Congress, I continue to believe that the essential objective of conducting effective domestic surveillance in the War on Terror can be achieved without discarding our constitutionally protected civil liberties.

Thank you again for writing. Please stay in touch as this debate continues.

Sincerely,

Barack Obama
United States Senator

P.S. Our system does not allow direct response to this email. However, if you would like to contact me again, please use the form on the website: http://obama.senate.gov/contact/

Hey pssst, Obamabots. If you have read this far, let me just say that Obama is not the change you are looking for. YOU are the change you are looking for.

Get on the phone and call your senators.

Advertisements

4 Responses to “Text of Barack Obama’s constituent Email response letter for FISA HR 6304”

  1. confused Says:

    Obama’s email reply made more sense to me than your comments about it.

  2. Nijma Says:

    Strange bedfellows indeed, Jeff, when the libertarians can find common cause with Obama’s disaffected netroots. Could get interesting.

    That wasn’t really meant as a comment, Confused. More like I’m putting Obama’s official statement out there in public so people can read his position. There has been so much said about his position, and much of it pretty hard to believe, given his past statements supporting the Geneva Conventions, for example, that I wanted to hear it straight from the horse’s mouth and not have someone else interpret the Obama position for me.

    I’m not going to comment on Obama’s statement until I have a chance to read the entire FISA bill for myself. I have skimmed large portions of it and find it frightening. At this point if you want to get unconfused I would recommend reading |this| about how hurriedly and secretly the bill was jammed through the House of Representatives and |this| about the telecom companies and corruption in Congress. Or google Glen Greenwald–he seems to be following the bill the closest of anyone on the web. You can read the text of the FISA bill (HR 6304) |here|.

  3. carlos Says:

    estamo proud of obama in brazil, we are Brazilians support obama here in brazil support a black woman, called SUELY WALNUT FOR DELEGADA DISTRITAL ELÇÕES IN OCTOBER, PEDIMOS Q OBAMA SEND A MESSAGE OF SUPPORT TO NOGEUIRA SUELY DISTRITAIS OF ELECTIONS IN BRAZIL IN OCTOBER, It is VERY IMPORTANT FOR FOR NO’SE Q SUELY WALNUT SE ELEJA BEST IN BRAZIL TO REPRESENT THE BRAZILIAN Q SOFREM VERY MINORITIES FOR OBAMA U.S. is OUR HERO, IT REPRESENT ALL IN WHAT DESEJAMOS FOR BRAZIL, PLEASE SEND A MESSAGE OF SUPPORT The CANDIATURA SUELY OF ELECTIONS IN WALNUT DISTRITAIS OF BRAZIL, is VERY IMPORTANT FOR U.S., WE THANKS WITH OBAMA, PLEASE SEND THIS MESSAGE OF SUPPORT TO SUELY NOGUEIRA, CANDIDATA HE IS THE BLACK ELEIÇÕERS DISTRITAIS IN BRAZIL, RESPRESNTA IS IN HERE, SO HOW TO OBAMA IN THE WORLD. CARLOS SANTOS THANKS


Comments are closed.